Decaf Coffee Selection

Amaretto is a medium roast that tastes of almonds, having a sweet marzipan flavor reminiscent of holiday magic.

1 lb. Bag (454 g)

Apple crumb cake is a fruity, light, complex coffee beloved by our local customers for its unique flavor. Brew it up to serve with a cobbler, coffee cake, or apple fritters.

Bananas Foster is a medium roast which tastes of buttery bananas, rich brown sugar, with slight hints of cinnamon spice and rum.

This flavored coffee sounds pretty fantastical, doesn’t it? Almost like it’s come right out of a fairy tale, doesn’t it? Well we’re not pulling your leg on this one! Blueberry Cinnamon Crumble is just as the name entails, and provides our quality coffee with the flavor of a blueberry cinnamon crumble pie! Should you believe such a fanciful tale? Don’t just take our word for it! Try some for yourself!

Bourbon Streusel Cake is a medium roast coffee that tastes like rich, sweet, nutty coffee cake with light bourbon top notes.

Butterscotch Toffee is a medium roast coffee with a lightly spiced, creamy caramel flavor with rummy notes.

A cashew and a caramel candy walked into a bar. They ordered Lukewarm Caramel Cashew in a 1lb. Bag. The bartender said “You two don’t look like you weigh more than about two ounces. And we don’t serve anything under 16". Jokes aside, we’d like you to enjoy our coffee with the flavor of cashews and caramel. Now in 1 lb. form!

In our experience, slow and steady NEVER wins races. You can be the steadiest, slowest person in the world, and still never win a single race. The only race you can ever hope to win is a race for how slow anything could be, which would be a boring race anyways. Just keep racking up those participation trophies, my turtle compadre, and enjoy some of our chocolate turtle coffee. Chocolate, caramel, and the flavor of nuts speed this into first place for your favorite coffee! Lukewarm Coffee will never leave you in the dust, when it comes to quality coffee and robust flavor! So run, don’t walk, to order this delicious brew today!

Cinnamon Hazelnut is a medium roast coffee that is just the perfect blend of exotic cinnamons and classic hazelnut with a hint of vanilla cream.

1 lb. Bag (454 g)

Think Pumpkin Spice is good? This flavor is back by popular request!

Cinnamon Sweet Potato Swirl is a medium roast coffee bursting with all the gooey warmth of a freshly-baked sweet potato casserole. It’s buttery, it’s marshmallowy, and it’s got that lovely hint of cinnamon spice swirled in. This sweeter, mellow sister to Pumpkin Spice will have you smiling through the holidays.

Crumb Cake is a medium roast coffee featuring flavors like vanilla and cinnamon to imitate a lovely pastry. Now you can have you cake and drink it, too.

A medium roast coffee infused with buttery white chocolate to make a smooth white mocha.

Fireside Marshmallow is a medium roast with a flavor that evokes the childhood memories of toasting marshmallows over a bonfire on a clear summer night.

The Legend of the Fireside Marshmallow Man:
Unlike Big Foot, Nessie, the Moth Man or other freaky legendary creatures, the Fireside Marshmallow Man could be harmful to your health! It seems he preys on folks who enjoy a good toasted marshmallow by the campfire… BUT not just anyone enjoying marshmallows. He seems to be taking vengeance on those who jam the stick in their marshmallow, shove it directly into the fire, and allow it to burst into flames. They then let it burn to a black charcoal crust, blow it out, and, with a maniacal laugh, squeeze the soft white middle into their mouths! These are the ones the Fireside Marshmallow Man seems to be targeting.
If you are one of these sadistic marshmallow crazies, BEWARE! You may find yourself on the wrong end of the ole marshmallow stick! So try to enjoy this wonderful toasted marshmallow-flavored coffee while you can!

Here in the Midwest, you’ll see beautiful sunsets and gorgeous sunrises over never-ending corn, corn, and more corn. It can get a little monotonous: all the flatland and fields. Thankfully, there are mythical beings out making mythical brews. This flavor combination of Rum, vanilla, and pecan makes for the perfect coffee when sitting around and enjoying the predictable Midwest scenery!

French Vanilla is a medium roast coffee with vanilla made the French way with a dash of spice in a caramelized background.

It’s beginning to look a lot like Christmas… Six months early. Snowmen and Santas are in every store, and pine-scented candles line the shelves. You haven’t even dusted off your Halloween decorations from the attic before you are bombarded with the festive fist of the holly jolly holiday. You cannot escape it, so give into your Christmas urges! Try some Frosty’s Favorite, and bring a little bit of winter wonderland with you anywhere and at any time of the year! With hints of ho-ho hazelnut, garland graham cracker, and very-merry vanilla, Christmas never, ever has to go away! Doesn’t that just jingle your bells?

1 lb. Bag (454 g)

Fur ony o' ye scots folks, we ken howfur yer feelin' whin it comes tae bein' far fae hame. Tis solid whin na yin understands ye, 'n' yer accent. Tis enough tae juist mak' ye awa wi ye tae bile yer heid 'n' haud yer wheesht! Weel keep the heid! We 'ere at Lukewarm Coffee kin pat a bawherr scott back intae yer lee! Introducing Teuchter Grogg, a taps aff coffee tae remind ye o` yer days in th' moors! Wi' th' combined flavor micht o' butterscotch 'n' rum, ye'll be back tae yer auld scots sel again! We cannae guarantee that ye'll fit back intae yer auld kilt, bit it ne'er hurts tae huv a go!

For those who aren’t Scottish, allow us to translate: Highlander Grogg© has hints of butterscotch and rum! It’s good! Try some!

If you could have any coffee on a deserted island, which coffee would you take with you? We don’t want to make a decision for you, but may we recommend our “Jamaican Me Crazy©” as a nominee? With flavor combinations of Kahlua, vanilla, and caramel, it could possibly make your days as a castaway feel like a walk on the beach! Jamaican Me Crazy© can perk you up enough to help with the tedium of everyday life: such as drawing a giant “HELP” in the sand, and trying to pick out what leaf loincloth to wear today.

Yo ho, yo ho, a pirate’s life for us thanks to this famous brew overflowing with caramel, Kahlua, and pecan: a combination so delicious it should be rated Arrr. But don’t take our word for it, ye landlubbers! This nautical favorite can be yours to try from the stable ground of your own kitchen floorboards. It’s sure to give you the extra kick you need to navigate the day no matter what storms loom on the horizon.

Make yourself a Jazzy Java with this smooth roast brimming with buttered rum, sizzlin’ cinnamon, and roasted pecans.

You’re sure to fall in love with the sweet, rich coffee kissed so perfectly with chocolate it melts on your taste buds.

Peppermint Mocha is a medium roast of rich chocolate with a sweet minty background.

1 lb. Bag (454 g)

Pumpkin Pecan is a medium roast coffee infused with delightful pumpkin spices which are mellowed out with delicious buttery pecans.

Pumpkin Spice Crème: a pumpkin spice latte infused directly into the beans available all year! For Autumnal celebrations, add more pumpkin spice, more crème, and your favorite over-sized knit sweater. Serve in a an orange mug which reads something like: live, laugh, love.

Pralines & Cream is a medium roast made with nutty pralines and caramelized sugar.

Carried full-time by popular demand: Red, White + Blueberry is a medium roast coffee infused with perfectly ripened mixed berries coated in white chocolate. This sweet and fruity brew is what got our customers through the truly chaotic year that was 2020. As a testament to it’s calming qualities, we have decided to carry it as part of our regular Lukewarm Flavored Coffee collection.

Enjoy this medium roast coffee infused with the modern, irresistible flavor combination of sweet creamy caramel and pink Himalayan salt.

Are you coo-coo for cookies? Could you just gobble them up by the guinea sack full? Well our snickerdoodle-doo flavored coffee ought to ruffle your feathers! With the taste of cinnamon and nutty tones, you’ll feel as proud as a pea-fowl as you enjoy this cookie-style coffee! What do cookies have to do chicken puns? We don’t know! It’s too much for our little bird brains to figure out. But don’t let that prevent you from enjoying this coffee confection!

A medium roast coffee infused with the Bean Counter’s very own specialty sugar cookies that our locals rave about. Try it for yourself!

Vermont Maple Nut is a rich mountain of maple flavor with just a hint of nut. Pair this brew with a stack of hot flapjacks with the same fixin’s for a breakfast that’s out of this world!